Paige R. Butler | Rosemarie E. Arnold

Aggressive Representation & Personal Service – “A Courtroom Bulldog Who Won’t be Leashed”

Settlement of $3,450,000.00:

In a motor vehicle case involving a Guttenberg woman who was a driver involved in a head-on collision with a motor vehicle negligently operated by a car dealership's employee resulting in catastrophic injuries. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $8,125,000:

In a motor vehicle case involving a New York man who was a passenger involved in a head-on collision in Cochecton, New York, causing him to sustain fractures and head injuries. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $5,120,000:

After successfully obtaining a jury verdict of $7,400,000 in a case involving a Hackensack cardiologist who sustained catastrophic injuries after being forcefully knocked down as a pedestrian by a motor vehicle. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $3,000,000:

In a case involving an infant who sustained blindness after she bent down to pick up a toy and her left eye contacted a sharp protruding bar from a display rack. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Jury Verdict of $1,600,000:

In a case involving a man who sustained catastrophic injuries when a vehicle in front of him negligently ran over a tire, propelling it and knocking him off his motorcycle. Read More

Settlement of $1,500,000:

In a case involving a Teaneck woman who was injured when, as a pedestrian, she was struck by a vehicle causing her to become pinned between two vehicles. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $1,800,000 :

in a case involving a Staten Island teenager who sustained injuries after having been shot in his eye with a BB-Gun pellet. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $1,200,000:

In a case involving an East Rutherford woman who was injured when she was struck as a pedestrian lawfully crossing a crosswalk in Hackensack, New Jersey. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $965,000:

In a case involving a Rochelle Park man who sustained injuries while he was working as a forklift operator when the forklift flipped over and pinned him underneath the roll cage. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Jury Verdict of $750,000:

In compensatory damages plus $10,000 in medical expenses in a case involving a Middlesex County woman who was sexually assaulted by two on-duty uniformed police officers employed by New Jersey Transit Police Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $1,300,000:

for four employees of the Township of Howell claiming discrimination and a hostile work environment against the township, the township municipal court, and Court Administrator. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Settlement of $4,000,000:

In cash and benefits for her client in a lawsuit filed against Bergen County, New Jersey for allowing their employee to force Arnold’s client to perform fellatio on him. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Confidential 7 figure settlement:

In a suit brought on a behalf of the brother of world renowned playwright Leonard Melfi whose dead body was desiccated and buried in a mass grave. Read More

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Paige R. Butler

NY Managing Attorney

Location:

Phone:

(201) 461-1111

Fax:

(201) 461-1666

Email:

Email me

Attorney Paige R. Butler Selected In 2022 Thomson Reuters Rated By Super Lawyers

Paige R. Butler is a Partner and the New York Managing Attorney, specializing in personal injury cases throughout New Jersey and New York. Paige represents clients in cases involving automobile accidents, premises liability, medical malpractice, sexual harassment, employment discrimination, and wrongful death. She has been with the firm since 2008, where she has spent her career advocating for her clients, in all forms of resolution and trial settings, obtaining multi-million dollars in settlements and verdicts. Paige has provided her legal analysis on a variety of topics as a guest contributor for various televised news shows and has received numerous awards in the legal field, including being named a New Jersey Super Lawyers Rising Star every year since 2013. Paige is determined to promote her client’s best interests, and always strives to humanize the legal process for her clients with compassion and honesty.

TV Appearances:

Your World with Neil Cavuto, Fox News

Fox and Friends

CBS News

Trial Verdicts:

Oates v. New York City Transit Authority, Index No. 302214-07

Woman Struck and Killed by NYC Transit Bus - $950,000 Verdict

Bronx Supreme Court, June 2013

Featured in New York Verdict Search Magazine

Settlements:

8,800,000 – Medical Malpractice, Failure to Diagnose

8,250,000 – Automobile Accident, Traumatic Brain Injury

7,867,423 – Premises/Elevator Incident

3,450,000 – Automobile Accident, Cervical & Elbow Injury

1,605,000 – Premises Liability/Fire/Fault Alarm System

1,500,000 – Automobile Accident, Pedestrian

1,500,000 – Dog Bite, Facial Injury

1,300,000 – BB Gun Incident

1,162,600 – Premises Liability/Fall Down in Cafeteria

1,100,000 – Teacher/Student Sexual Harassment

1,000,000 – Automobile Accident/Pedestrian

825,000 – Products Liability/Injury by Nail Gun

750,000 – Premises Liability/Struck by Forklift

700,000 – Sports/Participant Struck by Soccer Ball

Areas Of Practice

Litigation & Appeals
Personal Injury -- Plaintiff
Motor Vehicle Accidents -- Plaintiff
Premises Liability
Dog Bites
Wrongful Death
Employment Discrimination
Sexual Harassment
Sports Injuries
Products Liability

Bar Admissions

New Jersey, 2008
New York, 2009
U.S. District Court District of New Jersey, 2008
U.S. District Court Southern District of New York

Education

Albany Law School of Union University, Albany, New York
- J.D. - 2008
SUNY Binghamton University, Binghamton, New York
- B.A. - 2005
- Honors: Dean's List
- Major: Philosophy, Politics and Law